Table of Contents

The Perfect Cover Letter: Advice From a Lit Mag Editor on Standing Out

Most job seekers have that nagging fear their cover letter will just vanish into a black hole, but honestly, a solid one really can make a difference. The perfect cover letter is short, clear, and shows you actually get what the company’s looking for. Try to use the hiring manager’s name if you can dig it up, keep things professional, and spell out—without rambling—why you’d be a great fit.

An editor at a desk with a stack of manuscripts, a cup of coffee, and a framed magazine cover on the wall

A strong cover letter? Just a handful of quick paragraphs—maybe 100 to 150 words, tops. Start with a brief intro, drop in a key skill or win, and wrap up with a simple thank you. If you’re tired of writing the same thing over and over, tools like RoboApply can save you some headaches—automating applications, scoring resumes, and whipping up custom cover letters that actually get attention. You can even try RoboApply for free if you want to see how it works.

Understanding the Purpose of a Cover Letter

A cover letter is basically your professional handshake—whether you’re applying for a job or sending work to a lit mag. It should be direct, not too wordy, and show you in the best professional light you can muster.

Why Editors Value a Strong First Impression

Editors are busy folks—they’re skimming through dozens, sometimes hundreds, of submissions. That first impression can stick, for better or worse. Even if it’s just a few lines, a professional cover letter shows you’re serious and know how things are usually done.

Here’s a quick example:

Dear [Magazine Editor’s Name],

I am submitting my short story, “Blue Monday,” for your consideration. My work has appeared in several online magazines, including Fiction Weekly and Daily Words. Thank you for your time and consideration. I look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,
Taylor Hill

Notice how it’s short, polite, and mentions relevant publication history? There’s no need to explain the story or brag. Editors can usually tell from the letter if you’re reliable and get their vibe. Keeping it simple and courteous really does help. If you want more insight, check out The Perfect Cover Letter: Advice From a Lit Mag Editor.

Distinguishing Cover Letters From Submission Forms

Cover letters let you introduce yourself and your intentions, while submission forms are just there to collect the basics—name, contact, title, genre. No room for personality there.

But with a cover letter, you get a shot at showing you understand the audience and the process. Editors notice when someone puts in the effort versus when they just fill out a form. Being able to write a tailored cover letter can really separate you from the crowd.

On job sites like LinkedIn or Indeed, you can usually upload a cover letter with your resume. Tools like RoboApply can help with resume scoring, cover letter writing, and applying faster across the web.

Keep it specific, under a page, and use it to make yourself memorable. If you need a hand, Try RoboApply for free.

Key Components of the Perfect Cover Letter

A stack of vibrant, carefully curated literary magazines sits on a desk, surrounded by a pen, notebook, and a cup of coffee

You want your cover letter to make a good impression right away. It should be tidy, easy to skim, and set a respectful, professional mood from the get-go.

Essential Contact Information

Always kick things off with your full name, phone, and email up top. Mailing address is pretty standard too, though for online stuff, digital-only is usually fine. If there are specific instructions, just follow them.

Example format:

Taylor Jones  
555-321-9876  
taylor.jones@email.com  
123 Oak Street  
Columbus, OH 43215

For email submissions, put this above your greeting. If you’re using a form, fill out their fields, but it doesn’t hurt to add your info at the top of your letter file too.

Clear contact info just makes it easier for them to reach out. Forgetting this stuff is a common (and annoying) mistake.

Crafting a Polished Salutation

Start with a specific salutation if you can. Address the hiring manager or editor by name, like “Dear Ms. Lee,” or “Dear Editor Johnson.” Check the job post, website, or masthead for a name. Skip “To Whom It May Concern” if you can help it.

If you really can’t find a name, “Dear Hiring Manager” or “Dear Editorial Team” works. It shows you tried.

Stick to last names unless told otherwise. A good greeting sets the right tone.

Templates and tools like Try RoboApply for free can help you find contact names and format everything so you look sharp—upping your odds of a good first impression.

Structuring Your Cover Letter for Success

A smartly organized cover letter helps the editor quickly see who you are and what you’re submitting. Getting the structure and length right shows you respect their time.

Effective Organization and Flow

A professional cover letter isn’t rocket science, but it should follow a clear path. Open with a greeting—“Dear Editor” or use their name, if you know it. The first line should say who you are and what you’re submitting.

Next, a quick note about the piece—genre, length, theme. If it’s a simultaneous submission (and they allow that), mention it. No need to overexplain or interpret your work—let the writing speak for itself.

Wrap up with a short thank you, like “Thank you for considering my submission.” Always double-check grammar, spelling, and formatting. Tools like Try RoboApply for free can help you catch mistakes and nail the structure.

Appropriate Word Count for Literary Submissions

Lit mag editors don’t want to read a novel in your letter. Keep it short—just a couple of paragraphs, between 100 and 150 words. Shorter letters are easier to read and more likely to get a response.

Here’s a quick layout:

Section Details
Greeting Dear Editor,
Introduction My name is Jane Doe. I am submitting my poem, “Winter Sun,” for your consideration.
Details The poem is 40 lines and explores the experience of change. This is a simultaneous submission.
Closing Thank you for your time and consideration.

Automated tools like Try RoboApply for free can help you draft, edit, and check your letters for length and formatting, so you don’t have to sweat the details.

Capturing the Editor’s Attention

A cover letter is usually the first impression you make on an employer or editor. If you want to stand out, write a clear synopsis and try to make it personal.

Writing a Compelling Synopsis

You’ve got just a few lines to show what you bring to the table. Focus on highlights—accomplishments, relevant skills, or unique experience. Ditch vague stuff. Instead of “I am a dedicated worker,” go with “I increased sales by 10% in my previous role by implementing a new marketing strategy.”

Here’s a simple template:

  • Start with your current job or skills: “As a customer service specialist with five years’ experience…”
  • Drop in a specific accomplishment: “…I led a team that improved client satisfaction scores by 15%.”
  • End with a clear connection to the job: “This experience aligns with your company’s focus on high-quality customer care.”

Get to the point and show your value right away. Tools like Try RoboApply for free can help you quickly match your experience to job requirements and punch up your intro.

Personalizing Your Approach

Personalization goes a long way. It shows you actually care about the company and did your homework. Address the letter to the hiring manager by name, if you can, and mention something specific about the company’s culture, values, or a recent win.

Example opening:

Dear Ms. Bennett,
I was excited to see your team’s recent award for community outreach. With my background in volunteer management, I feel connected to your mission and ready to add value.

Add a line about how your approach fits the job:

“Your commitment to client-centered service matches my belief in building long-term relationships.”

Do a little digging on company websites or LinkedIn for details. If you’re applying all over the place, Try RoboApply for free can help you quickly customize each letter and keep things organized, so you don’t fall into the “generic” trap.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

A stack of rejection letters surrounded by crumpled paper and a frustrated writer staring at a blank computer screen

A cover letter can really help—or totally tank—your application. Little slip-ups, like using the same tired phrases or blasting out the same letter to everyone, just make you look uninterested.

Overused Phrases and Clichés

Hiring managers wade through a mountain of cover letters every day. When a letter is packed with stuff like “team player,” “hard worker,” or “go-getter,” it just sort of fades into the background. Those words don’t actually prove anything. Instead of saying, “I’m a motivated self-starter with excellent communication skills,” it’s way more convincing to share a quick story:

  • “I led a team of five on a tight deadline and delivered the project early.”

Basically, it’s better to show what you’ve done than just toss in buzzwords. Cutting out the fluff makes your cover letter sharper and way more persuasive.

List of common clichés to avoid, plus what to try instead:

Cliché Better Option
Results-oriented professional Describe a result you achieved
Team player Show how you worked with a group
Go above and beyond Explain a time when you took extra steps

Submitting a Generic Cover Letter

Sending out the same cover letter to every job? Honestly, that’s a missed chance. Generic letters usually skip over company names, don’t mention job titles, and don’t really show how you fit the role. It kind of tells the hiring manager you didn’t care enough to look into the company.

A strong cover letter actually addresses the employer by name and ties your experience to what they need. For example:

  • “I am excited to apply for the Marketing Associate position at Bright Future Media, where my social media campaign generated 200% growth in student engagement.”

If you want to speed things up but still send something custom, tools like RoboApply can help whip up targeted cover letters that actually match your skills to each job. If you’re jumping between LinkedIn, Indeed, and all those other sites, you can Try RoboApply for free.

Expert Tips From a Lit Mag Editor

A desk cluttered with manuscripts, a laptop, and a mug of coffee. A framed magazine cover hangs on the wall

A great cover letter for a literary magazine is more than just a polite hello—it’s a quick way to show editors you’re serious and that you actually know what they publish. Editors see a ton of submissions, so a professional cover letter can help you stand out.

Showcasing Professionalism and Passion

Editors notice when someone’s taken a minute to look up their name or learned something about the publication. Using the editor’s name instead of a generic greeting feels way more personal. For example, a strong opening sentence could be: “Dear Ms. Taylor, I am excited to submit my short story, ‘Winter Light,’ for your consideration at Bluebird Review.”

It’s smart to mention why your work fits their style. Maybe something like: “After reading the Spring 2024 issue, I felt my work aligned with Bluebird Review’s focus on quiet, reflective fiction.” It shows you’ve actually read the magazine and care about where your work appears.

Most lit mags expect a short, third-person bio at the end, too. Something simple works:

Jane Smith is a writer from Ohio whose work has appeared in Sunflower Journal and Maple Leaf Magazine.

If you’re tired of rewriting the same letter, tools that help you tailor and polish your cover letter for every submission can really save time. If you’re curious, Try RoboApply for free for some quick customization and edits.

Maintaining Clarity and Conciseness

Editors are busy. They want cover letters that are short and get right to the point. The sweet spot is about 150-200 words. Skip the long backstories, don’t apologize for not having a long list of credits, and don’t repeat what’s in your manuscript.

A good, simple structure is:

  1. Greeting and a quick connection to the editor or magazine
  2. One sentence about what you’re submitting
  3. Short author bio
  4. Polite closing

For example:

Dear Ms. Taylor, I am submitting my short story, “Winter Light,” to Bluebird Review. I admire the magazine’s dedication to reflective fiction, which matches my work’s themes. Jane Smith is a writer from Ohio, recently published in Sunflower Journal. Thank you for considering my work.

If you’re applying for a lot of jobs or submissions, tech can help. Platforms like Try RoboApply for free can help you measure how well your cover letter works or just get the writing done faster.

Final Thoughts on Submitting Your Cover Letter

A stack of cover letters on a desk, next to a laptop and a cup of coffee. A framed magazine cover hangs on the wall

Paying close attention to detail and tweaking your cover letter for each submission can really help you stand out. Spending a few extra minutes to review your work is worth it when you know how many editors and hiring managers skim through piles of applications.

Double-Checking Before Sending

Before you hit send, it’s worth doing a quick review for accuracy and completeness. Here’s a handy checklist:

  • Double-check the recipient’s name and the publication or company.
  • Make sure spelling, grammar, and formatting look professional.
  • Attach any documents or writing samples they asked for.
  • Confirm your contact info is up to date.

Typos or missing info can make it seem like you didn’t care, and that’s never good. Reading your letter out loud or having a friend look it over can catch things you might miss.

If you want a little backup, grammar checkers or review platforms like Try RoboApply for free can help flag weak spots or missing details, or even give your letter a score.

Adapting for Different Literary Magazines

Every literary magazine (or publisher) has its own quirks and guidelines. You’ll want to tweak your cover letter’s content and tone for each one. Always follow the submission instructions—sometimes it’s about theme issues, sometimes word count, or maybe they want a short bio.

Only list previous publication credits that actually fit the magazine’s style or audience. If you’re new to publishing, a quick line about your background or why you like the magazine is just fine.

Some magazines love personal touches—like mentioning a favorite story they published. Others just want you to keep it businesslike. Picking up on these details shows respect for the editor’s time and could give you a leg up.

If you’re juggling a lot of submissions, tools like Try RoboApply for free can help you keep track of requirements and make quick edits for each magazine.

Frequently Asked Questions

A strong cover letter is clear, straight to the point, and tailored for the magazine you’re sending it to. Good formatting, a polite tone, and a bit of research can make your letter way more memorable.

What are the essential elements to include in a cover letter for a literary magazine submission?

Include the editor’s name if you can find it, your piece’s title, genre or category, and a short description of what you’re sending. Mentioning word count and adding a short, professional bio is also helpful. Keep it respectful and concise. For more examples, check out this lit mag editor’s advice.

How can you tailor a cover letter to catch an editor’s attention?

Editors notice when writers do their homework. Address the editor by name if possible, and mention something specific about the magazine—maybe a theme or a recent issue. Personalizing your letter shows you actually care about this magazine, not just any publication. Explaining why your piece fits their style can also make a difference.

What are common mistakes to avoid when writing a cover letter to a literary journal?

Long-winded cover letters and over-the-top self-praise usually backfire. Editors also dislike letters that are clearly generic or sent to a bunch of magazines without any changes.

Avoid dramatic language, don’t retell your entire story, and skip unrelated info. The key is to keep it short and focused.

Could you provide some effective strategies for making a cover letter stand out to a lit mag editor?

Introduce your work briefly and mention any relevant publications or experience. If you don’t have credits, just say you’re an emerging writer—no need to apologize.

Name the magazine and connect your work to their themes. If you want help polishing your letter or tracking submissions, Try RoboApply for free is a handy tool.

What should writers understand about the submission process before sending a cover letter and their work to a lit mag?

Read and follow the submission guidelines carefully. Every journal has its own rules about document type, length, and format.

Be patient—response times can vary a lot. Some journals allow simultaneous submissions, but always double-check their policy first.

Are there any specific formatting guidelines to follow when creating a cover letter for literary magazine submissions?

Generally, most journals just want cover letters in a standard business letter format. That means left-aligned text, single spacing, and a blank line between paragraphs—nothing fancy. Start with a greeting, and don’t forget your contact information up top.

You’ll want to pick a clean, readable font—11 or 12 point usually does the trick. And honestly, it’s worth double-checking for typos before you hit send. If you’re not sure about formatting or want a shortcut, there are some automated tools out there that can help, like RoboApply, which you can try for free.

AI-Powered Career Tools

Share the Post:

Most Recent Blogs

Read More
Read More
Read More
Read More
Read More
Read More